Showing posts with label Engineering. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Engineering. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 24, 2025

Rage Triggered by Incompetence

I originally wrote this piece in May 2024, but did not post or otherwise disclose this writing at the request of the person who was most directly impacted.  What is not captured here is that in July 2024 the Board of Trustees assured that the insitution's President reigned for personal reasons and stepped headlong into the chasm that had been created, to the point that one of their own, Mr. David Heacock, became acting President and indeed pulled us back from the brink.  For that reason I am now posting this reflection of the circumstances of that time as it ought to be an object lesson that, as I saw in my second tour in Iraq, leadership matters and we can, indeed, turn from rage to stalwart resolve and actions for the better.

 

20 May 2024


Today something I have dreaded, happened.  I had rage, serious rage, return.  One could call this post-dramatic stress, and that might be right, but is something that really has hit me strongly.  The reason for being “triggered” is acute, but the circumstances are absolutely not unique.  That said, this is rivaling one of the worst experiences with leadership that I have had in my entire life.

 

To begin, then, let’s first give the backstory.  For those that know me, know that I am a 20 plus year US Army veteran.  Thanks to serving in combat for two tours, I often wear my Operation Iraqi Freedom hat as I come and go.  But let me tell you, my two tours in combat, when it came to leadership, couldn’t be more starkly different.  Someday, when I write my recollections of my service, the working title will be “A Tale of Two Tours:  An Engineer Officer in Combat during Operation Iraqi Freedom” and I have more or less decided on the opening, borrowing from Charles Dickens (and the book from which my working title is drawn), “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times …”[1]  Rather than try to put into text the tale of my first tour in Iraq, I will share with you a message (sermon) I gave about it, that was recorded on video because we were in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic lock-downs during the summer of 2020:  https://youtu.be/5R2f7z8Ejjk?si=uBxMwY8X_i8_9WxV&t=623.  Starting at the 6:23 mark and going until 17:33, I recall a vivid memory that I will never be able to fully get out of my head.  I did not “change the names to protect the innocent”, if you are wondering.[2]  And to be succinct, this is the PG version of events, as I don’t get into the graphic details, and as a part of a sermon on the issues of passing judgement, well, it made no sense to get into those details.  I will just say that was the early bottom.  And it was just one of many reasons to have long lasting anger about the tour, especially the leadership above me, and their utter failures, misjudgments, and incompetence, in the face of very real needs for strong leadership, people of strong moral character, and a willingness to have a vision for more than their own benefits and their own careers or legacies.  Rage is simply the best word that I have about what happened to me and to those that stood with me in the midst of unspeakable challenges, brutally harsh conditions, and a nearly impossible mission because of the failures of these supposed leaders.

 

It is to this past that I am triggered.  To a past that literally nearly killed people because of the failures of leadership that I witnessed, in my then fairly early career as a military officer.  Lessons that I learned and cannot unlearn about leadership.  Its lessons like how one can ascertain the leadership capabilities of someone else, one need only look at those that said someone else surrounds themselves with.  Are they surrounded with those that are going to challenge the leader and each other such that the leader can distil, from vigorous yet honest debate, the best path forward?  Or are they wanting a coterie of those that simply are “yes” people and/or sycophants that stoke the ego of the person in charge, being uncritical and unwilling to stop failures moral, ethical, legal, or otherwise, either among themselves or by the supposed leader?  Or are they surrounded by a brutish bunch that are out for self-interest, caught up in pet theories, doctrinaire to a fault, and unwilling to acknowledge, never mind apologize for, mistakes made?  Or are they wanting to be seen as the “smartest person in the room” by ensuring those around them can never challenge them or that they are ignorant of the failures and incompetence of those around them because they so clearly have no interest in getting the ground truth?  Yes, you can see very clearly who is a leader and is not, if you ask these questions and more.  And the rage I feel is based on many more lessons I have learned in and out of combat, some of the worst examples came from this first tour in Iraq.

 

So, what has me enraged?  Simply put, I am a part of an institution that is at a precipice.  While no one is being asked to put their life on the line for this organization, it is an organization that has, for me (and many others) deep and abiding roots.  It is an organization that should it fail, will have devastating effects on the livelihoods of those it employs, devastating effects on the very economic foundation of the community it resides within, and devastating effects on those that found their very selves while traversing a very influential part of their lives on its campus(es).  As an institution, it should not be in the conversation about these lackluster possibilities, given its focus on engineering, business, the sciences, and other national needs.  It is a haven for those that take seriously their future and it has, at its bones, the results, amazing results, which prove it can stand the test of time.  It is here, when as an industry many are in much worst starting positions, worse inherent fundamentals, and seeing many failures result in utter shuttering of their enterprises, that this otherwise “ahead of the game” institution is experiencing some of the worst leadership failures and tolerance of utter incompetence, negating all of its advantages.  As I relayed to a Vice President as little as 8 months ago, the institution had about 2 years of runway, financially, culturally, and humanly, to get on the right track.  But it’s hard to see how the choices that have been made in interim have done anything more than to squander even that limited set of benefits.

 

And today’s exceptionally poor choice took the cake; well fecal pie in actuality.  One of the saving graces of the institution in question has been its ability to capitalize on professional graduate education.  It has been able to leverage its position as a well-respected and, in several areas, foremost institution for engineering, science and business, to attract and educate those seeking a degree beyond the bachelor’s degree.  And while undergraduate enrollment has been slipping, and this year in free fall, since 2016, the professional graduate enrollment numbers have been steady, if not climbing, through the same period.  At the helm of this stable, “going well despite other headwinds,” result has been two good stewards for this effort, with the most recent being a woman of unassuming but fantastic abilities (leadership, academic, research, business, and more).  Repeating, in other words, basically saving the bacon of the institution has been a remarkable person, unparalleled in emotional, never mind raw, intelligence, wise well beyond her years, capable of doing twice as much with half the resources, and putting her loyalty in the institution as an alum, and as a member of the institution’s very DNA, above her own self-interests.  Full disclosure, the person directly involved, whom I just lavished significant praise, is a personal friend whom I have known since we were undergrads at the same institution we now serve.  That said, regardless of personal feeling, the facts are incontrovertible.  To this person, the President, after having snubbed her once and putting in a completely unqualified person in a position above her, was again highly insulted by telling her, and I quote:  “As a part of your role as Dean of the Graduate Studies,[3] you have done a commendable job in overseeing graduate recruiting.[4]  It is in Clarkson’s best interest moving forward[5] to centralize admissions under one Vice President.[6]  The decision has been made to do that under the VP of Strategic Enrollment Management.[7]”  So, to shorten, you’re doing an amazing job, let’s give it to a guy[8] who is failing at what he is supposed to be doing, because I don’t give a crap about actual results.

 

My response, once reading the memo that was perfunctorily sent to her, was “Bullshit!”  I went on to say, “So it’s working (well), so I need to fuck it up.  Well done [President’s first name].”  Long and short this is the kind of ineptitude, failure of leadership, and doubling down on incompetence that I loathe, and in other situations has resulted in the near death of those in combat.  There is no good reason to do this, NONE!  This is pure unadulterated failure to see the forest for the trees.  It’s doubling down on failure.  It’s the sickest, darkest, and most profound mockery of any semblance of leadership I have seen since those dark days I experienced in Iraq in 2003-2004.  But unlike then, I no longer have the rose tinted glasses, nor, given the situation, the obligation to sit quietly by within the restrictions of the chain of command.  I am many years wiser and many leadership experiences older, to know what pseudo-leadership is and what true leadership looks like.  This is no Lee Iacocca that has come to this institution to pull us out of our doldrums, this is another Bernie Madoff that is playing it for all he and those that go along with him can get.  It’s horrible, and it’s wrong.  It needs to end.

 

And this is even more why I am enraged.  I am not fully sure how to cut through the bullshit.  As a part of a group of loyalists trying to right the ship, we seem to be in an endless cycle of plugging yet another hole created by the administration, using the deck gun to shoot another self-inflicted hole through the hull.  The ship need not leak this bad, but they are incapable of doing anything more than doing harm.  One would hope that the trustees, who are supposed to be asking the hard questions, looking out for the long term future of the institution, supposed to be making sure that it remains there in perpetuity, and not taking anything for granted, cut through the façade.  I/we need to figure that out, I/we really do.  Because, as much as it can be the hardest thing in the world, doing the harder right over the easier wrong, in the end, does win the day.  That is the lesson of the second of two combat tours has taught me.  Leadership matters, and despite the problems, true leaders can and will come to the fore.  So as much as I am angry, ready to lash out, it is that discipline that I have honed for too many years, which will serve us well.  The path (gate) may be narrow, but it exists.  It seems now to be a light, yet dimly seen, in the distance.  I just pray it becomes brighter, clearer, and stronger, soon.

 



[1] Charles Dickens, Tale of Two Cities, full quote:  “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of light, it was the season of darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”

[2] And candidly, do not apologize.  The leadership failures were so utter, that I would be glad to stand in any court to relay the same tale, eternal or otherwise.

[3] Note:  the position is actually the “Dean of the Graduate School” (cf. University Organization Chart).  The President can’t even cite the proper name of the organization she is in charge of operating, which he is supposedly overseeing.

[4] Acknowledgement here that she is achieving success, well beyond what ought to be expected.

[5] “best interest moving forward”:  to be succinct there is nearly no evidence that the person making this decision actually knows what the best interests of the institution in question are.  Since his hiring, he has not secured one major donation nor has he done anything other than create an environment of distrust and austerity, often self-fulfilling.

[6] What basis is there for this?  None is given, and there is no evidence that there will be better results otherwise.  Basically, this is just not true.  Other examples of centralization over the last several years have proven disastrous.

[7] Who has been responsible for the lowest incoming class enrollment since the late 1980s or early 1990s.

[8] And it is a guy, not a gal.

Sunday, April 9, 2023

Avoiding Lobotomy - Again


As a junior officer in the US Army, and commonly spoken in the undercurrent among both Non-Commissioned Officers (NCOs) and junior officers alike, is the “Field Officer lobotomy”(https://www.reddit.com/r/army/comments/v5taom/majors_whats_wrong_with_you/).  This is the thing that happens, somewhere in the development of an officer, typically when they are a Major, when they seemingly forget the basics of how the Army runs, and get lost into some rabbit hole while stuck in the long period between company command and battalion command.  It’s as if we just loose sense of what is “common sense” as well as being grounded in (and with) the very challenging realities of troops at the company level and below.  It’s as if all the staff and broadening “special assignments” time you spend puts you into some esoteric death spiral.  Sure you’re smart or capable, etc, but you’ve become this amorphous blob of uncertainty, indecision, and constant incapability because you’ve lost that command touch.  The vast majority of officers succumb at some point, as if they become “company men” or “women”, and accept the utter stupidity and core failings in the systems instead of seeking to work to challenge them and make for better systems or simply level with folks about the absurdity of it all.


In my military career, I worked really hard, I mean really hard, to not get/have said lobotomy.  Part of this was done by not taking the “normal path”, by eschewing just going with the flow from above as a way to get ahead.  Sure I didn’t run away from the core traditional command assignments (company and battalion command), but I found a way to do things that were impactful and as pragmatic as possible, in between.  That said, when it came to late 2016 and what I was going to do as I reached 20 years of service, I decided that micromanaging whether Johnny Joe or Jane soldier went to their dental appointment as a the way I was being measured as a commander in the Army Reserve, was ludicrous.  While it wasn’t the only reason to opt to decline a full command assignment (medical, career, and family reasons were more prominent), avoiding becoming lobotomized was also on the list.  Soldiers who served with me can tell you how successful or not I was at that task.  By summer 2017, however, I was heading to retirement, lest I succumbed.


So I am now on the cusp of yet another one of those “lobotomy” points.  In 2014 I went to the “dark side” in my career in the AEC (Architecture/Engineering/Construction) world:  I became a full time professor.  This said, I did so in a fashion that was atypical; I did not possess a doctorate.  In academia, these days, holding a PhD is normally the minimum prerequisite for such a role.  But instead I was hired to be a full time instructor and Director of the much more pragmatic Construction Engineering Management program at my alma mater, Clarkson.  If we look back at the history of engineering education, it was not until the 1970s that it became common that those serving as professors held doctorates.  Rather, it was more critical, nay the minimum prerequisite, that you had experience and knowledge that came from practice, demonstrated through licensure and robust professional credentials otherwise, rather than a having a background primarily as a researcher.  At Clarkson in particular, who’s motto is “a workman who needn’t not to be ashamed”, it was very common/valued that most faculty were consultants on the side and had a large portfolio of practical experience before and during their appointments.  Academia, for a variety of reasons, has turned to become research first, practical knowledge second, as the resume required in most settings.  And akin to the above undercurrent in the Army, it’s pretty much the unwritten rule that PhD means you have “pilled high and deep” a wall of theoretical knowledge that makes you lose the ability to have common sense or be grounded in the practical aspects of life.  And that stereotype is way too often more true than false, including a number of my colleagues in my department and beyond.


As I said, I am on the cusp of crossing that PhD line.  Not counting my chickens before they’re hatched, I still have to figure out how to get this last course done and finish the edits to my dissertation by the end of April, but the light outside that tunnel is very bright at this point.  So, if that happens, it’ll be Dr. Backus, fitting in with the crowd that is academia.  Now, strictly speaking, I did not have to pursue this.  I am a Professor of Practice at this point, something academia is finally realizing is needed; not, therefore, requiring a doctorate.  That said, there’s still a barrier to those without one to academic leadership (as was put by one person, “Erik doesn’t have a PhD so he can’t become chair, and shouldn’t remain as XO of the department”).  As I’ve seen time and time again, I’m more or less convinced that the fetish academia has with research, and the normal track for preparation and promotion for professors, is neither good nor healthy long term for the greater academy.  Running a lab, doing fundamental research, and publishing papers, does not prepare you well for become a leader of a department, school, college, etc.  And the things that are needed (eg organizational management & training, practical knowledge, leadership skills, etc.), are seen as almost anathema to gaining tenure and promotion (distractions, as one colleague put it).


So here am I, at that crossroads, about to become “one of them”, a “true academic”, with a doctorate and all to prove it.  I have no intent nor do I desire to work to gain tenure, expecting to remain a Professor of Practice through to retirement (although, I’d be very welcome, many years hence, to be considered for professor emeritus status, should that come about).  I made this pursuit, however, because it will open the doors to more senior leadership academically, given the current way things work, and it will alleviate my rather constant requirements to correct students from referring to me as “Doctor Backus” when I don’t have one.  I have always been a deep and big thinker.  I love learning, I remain ever curious and interested in expanding knowledge.  So I am not allergic to research (there’s parts of it I really like) and have been doing research even as far back as my Masters and in other roles in the military and when I was a practitioner in facilities organizations.  But I really think studying the ability to generate electrical power from lobsters (https://improbable.com/2013/02/06/renewable-power-source-search-lobsters/ ), while novel and cool, is utterly impractical and I am really not that interested in it.  I’m not saying that there isn’t a need for researching such things if they can lead to some real breakthrough, but it’s not my bag.  And to that, I hope it never becomes “my bag” as I stay rooted in the much more pragmatic, like making sure my students actually know how a toilet works, have had the experience of actually hammering a nail, as well as being able to do structural analysis, understand how to do concrete batch designs, size heating and cooling equipment, and build safer, better, and more resilient/sustainable infrastructure & buildings. I just do not want to be lobotomized away from what my experience and continuing practice allow me to do to bring value to my students, in the immediate sense, and through them, for the broader AEC community as a result.


I am going to say, hitting this milestone is something I remain sheepish and humble about.  The resume, so long as things finish as they should, will now list getting a PhD in 2023 (long removed from my Masters in 2004, so a late return to getting a terminal degree).  I will remain a bit of a unicorn, not fitting in exactly and pushing back against the consensus on what the broader academy needs to look like to remain relevant.  I do not believe one can be “over educated” as some seem to think happens here, when you’ve done a pursuit for a doctorate.  But I do get that we cannot and should not stare down our noses or exhibit the too often seen elitism that comes being in an academic ivory tower (evidenced just this week as senior academics poo-pooed the idea that a long-term decades-experienced, successful senior manager in the AEC world was not capable of teaching a masters level course in the “business of construction”, because he lacked an advance degree in business).  And I think engineering education, in particular, needs to return more to the practical, hands on, even trade skill training and education, that keeps us rooted.  I just don’t want to fit the moniker, I don’t want to be unable to relate to, empathize with, and understand the plumber, carpenter, iron worker in the field.  To me, being at the top of what I do means I help tomorrow’s construction (and, more broadly, AEC) leaders, grow in ways that brings better solutions than we come to today, working together and respectfully across backgrounds and experiences.  I just can’t succumb to a PhD lobotomy, in other words.  To that end, I hope those around me keep me grounded accordingly.

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Design – The Difference between Architects and Engineers

True Story:  this idea came to me in a dream last night.  It is a well-known fact that the two leading professions in the built environment, Engineers and Architects, think very differently and approach the challenge of answering how to build something from completely different angles.  Architects center their approach on the arts, while Engineers focus on the science and mathematics of the problem (if you will one is right brained and the other left brained).  And this dream also brought me back to a statement that my boss, an Architect, Cathy Wolfe stated in a meeting the other day, that when it comes to design (that part of either profession that needs creativity and iterative analysis) Engineers and Architects approach that very differently too.  She said that for Architects, “the design is defined early in the process and the rest is simply documentation.”  While for Engineers, she expressed, “they see design occurring throughout the process, and not complete until the end”.  Now enter my dream last night, where my mind literally re-entered this conversation again.  So in this dream, I envisioned my explaining this using an analogy of a Stone Sculptor/Architect or a Lego builder/Engineer.

David by Michelangelo (photo found at ducksters.com)

Let’s start with the Stone Sculptor.  Michelangelo is attributed in saying that “[i]n every block of marble I see a statue as plain as though it stood before me, shaped and perfect in attitude and action. I have only to hew away the rough walls that imprison the lovely apparition to reveal it to the other eyes as mine see it.”  After reflecting on this question of how Architect’s think about design, I more and more see that they design in the same terms as Michelangelo speaks of sculpting marble.  They establish a vision for what the structure or landscape is intended to be, and then simply work to describe and dictate what it is they already see in their minds eye.  And like a sculptor who uses his hammer and chisel to tap and chip and scrape away at the stone, Architects use color, and materials, and texture to hew a creation out of the earth.  The design is complete in the vision they have, and it’s a matter of documenting and bringing out the tactile reality that they see.  And it isn’t a violation of the “design” of something to tweak the precise elements of the structure or place to enable the vision they have to come to fruition, because they work towards the whole rather than trying to sum the parts.  The ultimate form is well defined, and the function fits within that context that is assumed to meet the needs presented.

David by Michelangelo made of Legos (photo found on funchannel.net)

Now on the other hand, let’s talk about the Engineer.  The engineer is all about the pieces the parts, the individual component and how it works and how it works together.  He has specific parts to pick from, a box of Legos to use to build his structure.  The color isn't critical, but it doesn't mean Engineers are blind to obvious poor aesthetics.  Building with Legos is all about one piece at a time, one thing after another, forming the answer, in a repeatable process.  It is iterative, and it is a system of systems, to an engineer, that makes the whole.  The function of each component addresses a specific need, solves a specific problem, which enables the most needs to be answered at the same time.  Several bricks can be used, but analysis dictates the “right” brick to match established patterns, best practices, and the inter-operability of the several systems that have to come together to meet the desired result.  Making a change in a brick selection is simply a “re-design” of the system.  Thus the design of something is not ever complete, as optimization and valuation builds one step to the next and can always be refined, always lubricated with creative juice, to perfect each individual piece to the point that the sum is the “well-oiled machine” they dream about.  Design for an engineer, is “an iterative process of trial and error, using rules of thumb and requiring experience” as I was told in my Structural Analysis lecture by John Thomsen.  And because of this drive to make perfect and optimize, Engineers are risk averse, they build in safety factors, they study failure obsessively to avoid it at all costs, and the idea of running to a vision on a whim is more than frightening, it’s apocryphal.  This, however, is wholly a human endeavor, as “[t]o Engineer is Human” as Dr. Henry Petroski plies in his well-read history of human achievement found in failure.


So as my unconscious was speaking to me, I gravitated to the need to share this image of a Lego Builder vice the Stone Sculptor.  I see both approaches as extremely valuable and valid.  The challenge is using the word “design” can oft be misused and misunderstood between Engineers and Architects.  Ideas about who ought to control what parts of a “design” are also challenging because on one side there is but one design and the other a process of design.  Frankly it requires a person who can hold both spheres in the tension and excitement that they make as the come together, to be able to maximize the creativity yielding the best results.  Vision and process cannot stand alone, and those that are “middle brained” can see how they interact and come together.  Perhaps the best start in this is recognizing how we see our mutual crafts, which I think these proxies can help us do.